Updated on 7 November 2026, by João Leite, Founder of murmur.

A screenshot of an AI answer proves one answer only, given in one conversation and on one day, and not the brand’s presence. The screenshot, the screen capture of the conversation, shows what the AI answered to that question, for that person, at that moment. Presence is how many answers the brand appears in, divided by the total number of answers. It is measured on a fixed list of questions, redone from time to time, and the screenshot comes alongside that number as an example. To count as a record, it goes with the exact question, the AI, the date, the place, the whole answer and the sources.

  • The list of brands almost never comes back the same. According to SparkToro, two answers to the same question in ChatGPT and in Google’s AI bring the same list less than 1% of the time.
  • Eight pieces of information go with the screenshot, from the question word for word to the list it came from.
  • The screenshot serves as an example, a record and a check: it gives a face to the presence number, keeps an error to ask for a correction and lets someone check the reading of the answer.
  • Presence, trend and cause call for the list of questions, redone in the same AI models, with the date of each round.

What a screenshot of an AI answer proves: one answer, in one conversation, on one day

A screenshot of an AI answer proves that the AI gave that answer to that question, in that conversation and on that day. The screenshot shows whether, in that answer, the brand was recommended, only mentioned, cited as a source, described with an error or left out. With the uncropped image and the question alongside, the reader checks what the AI said, word for word. The screenshot shows how the AI answered once, not how often it answers that way. In a meeting, it convinces because it is concrete, and it misleads for the same reason: one screen does not say whether it is the rule or the exception.

Why the same question returns a different list of brands

The same question returns a different list of brands because the AI writes each answer on the spot, and the screenshot freezes only one of those versions. SparkToro, an American audience research company, measured this variation with 600 volunteers and 12 questions that ask for a list of brands or products. There were 2,961 answers from ChatGPT, Claude and Google’s AI, collected in November and December 2025 and published in January 2026. Patrick O’Donnell, from Gumshoe.ai, a startup that sells brand monitoring in AI, ran the research with SparkToro.

In ChatGPT and in Google’s AI, two answers to the same question have less than a 1% chance of bringing the same list of brands. In Claude, by the same SparkToro calculation, the list comes back a little more often, but in the same order it is even rarer. Rand Fishkin, who signs the study, notes that newer models, the updated versions of each AI, may show more or less variation.

In ChatGPT, part of the difference between one answer and another may come from the person asking. OpenAI writes that ChatGPT infers the person’s region from the connection’s IP address and may use it when turning the question into searches. With memory turned on, it may also use in the search what the person said in other conversations. The other reasons are in the guide on why ChatGPT gives different answers to the same question.

murmur, a GEO agency in Brazil that places brands in the answers of ChatGPT, Claude, Google AIO and other AI agents, keeps the answer to every question it measures. The acronym Google AIO stands for AI Overview, the AI summary that Google shows at the top of many searches. The same set of questions runs week after week, and each answer is recorded and dated. None of these answers is collected on an employee’s computer: the collection runs on a server that murmur keeps in Brazil only for this task, connected to the internet through an address that does not change and with the browser set to Portuguese. That way the city of the person doing the measurement does not appear in the AI answers, and the ones kept in one week can be compared with those of the next. A stored answer shows one day only, and the brand’s presence comes from the whole list.

What the screenshot does not show: the brand’s presence, the trend and the cause

A screenshot does not show the brand’s presence, the trend, the cause of a change, whether the brand’s absence is the rule, nor sales.

The brand’s presence is a calculation over many answers, and the screenshot is only one of them. It asks for the buyer’s questions, from dozens to hundreds, asked in the same AI models. The guide on what counts as appearing in the answer says which answers go into that calculation. Every presence number is checked against its sample: who measured, what was counted, how many questions, which AI models and when.

The trend asks for two rounds of the same list, not two screenshots from different days. A round is each time the whole list is redone, and within it each question is asked more than once, on different days. Two rounds can only be compared in the same AI models and in the same way. Two loose screenshots may come from different accounts and places, and the difference between them does not say whether the brand went up. The rounds follow a calendar: every month, at minimum, and one extra when the AI changes model.

The cause also stays outside the screenshot. A screenshot taken after publishing a page does not show that the page brought the brand into the answer. The change may have come from another source, from a new model or from the AI’s natural variation. The cause is read in the same questions, before and after, and in the sources the answer started citing.

The brand’s absence in a screenshot is also just one answer. The next answer may bring the brand, and a screenshot without it does not prove that the AI never points to it.

The click and the sale stay outside the AI screen. The click appears in the company’s own Google Analytics, and the measurement guide shows how to separate the visits that come from AI.

What to keep with the screenshot for it to count as a record

Along with the screenshot, keep eight pieces of information, from the exact question to the list it came from, because each one changes the reading of the answer.

what to keepwhy to keep it
the question, word for wordanother sentence is another question for the AI
the AI, the model and whether web search was oneach AI and each model answer in its own way, and search brings the sources
the day and the timeanswers and sources change over time
the city, the account and the memoryin ChatGPT, the place and the memory may feed into the answer’s searches
the whole answer, in text, and the uncropped imagea crop may hide the caveat that changes the meaning
the sources the answer showed, with the URLthey hold what the AI used to answer
what the answer did with the brandrecommending the company and citing its site as a source are different things
the list and the round the screenshot came fromwithout them, nobody knows whether the screenshot is the rule or the exception

To know whether web search was on, OpenAI points to two signs: the search icon active in the input box or web sources cited in the answer. In ChatGPT, the answer that uses search may bring the sources as citations and, when the Sources button is available, in a separate list. Each source goes into the record with its full URL.

The place and the account of the person who asked go into the record because ChatGPT may use the region and the memory in searches. Note which city the question was asked from, whether there was a login and whether the conversation was new, with no history. The answer goes in full, in text, because a cut may leave out the caveat that changes the meaning. What the answer did with the brand also goes in writing, because being cited as a source is not the same as being recommended by the AI.

When a screenshot is useful: as an example, as an error record and as a check on the reading

A screenshot serves three purposes: as an example next to the number, as a record of an error and as a check on the reading. As an example, it shows the answer the buyer receives, and the number still supports the conclusion. As a record, the dated screenshot preserves an AI error about the company and accompanies the request to correct a site or Google. As a check, it and the saved text let you verify, in a sample, whether the count read each answer correctly. Outside these three uses, a screenshot promises more than it proves.

Where the screenshot fits in the report: after the brand presence number

In the report, the screenshot comes after the brand presence number, as an example of what that number counts. The number comes first, with the basis: the total number of questions, the AI models, the dates and the number of rounds. The rest of the report is in the measurement guide, in the answer about what to bring to a skeptical finance director.

After the number, choose screenshots that represent it: a question where the brand appeared, one where it dropped out and one that is hard to read. A gallery with only the best answers shows what is possible, not what is common. Each screenshot carries the question, the AI model and the date in its caption. For the conversation with the person who approves the budget, use the guide on how to explain GEO to your boss or the board.

How to check an AI answer screenshot that someone shows you

Ask the person who shows you the screenshot for the exact question, the AI model, the day, the list it came from and the total number of questions. Without that data, no outsider can ask the same question and see whether the brand comes back. Also ask for the uncropped image and the answers where the brand did not appear. A true crop can hide the rest of the answer, and the best screen among many shows the exception as if it were the rule. For the person who keeps it, the screenshot is a record; for the person who receives it without that data, it is a screen that nobody checks.

murmur puts the brand in the answers and shows the math behind the result

murmur puts the client’s brand in AI answers and shows the result as a calculation, with the sample alongside. A dedicated specialist analyzes the results, and it is the same person from the diagnostic onward. When murmur says the brand started being cited in a question, you can see the saved answer.

Mindo, a motion design studio in São Paulo and a murmur client, has its math published. In the same 134 questions, Mindo’s recommendation in ChatGPT rose from 12% to 23%. murmur measured in two rounds, on 25 and 26 June and on 13 and 14 July 2026. A screenshot would show the answer to one of the questions where ChatGPT recommended Mindo. The math shows, in each round, in how many of the 134 questions ChatGPT recommended Mindo, and that is what supports the comparison.

In the murmur dashboard, included in the service, the brand’s presence appears alongside each competitor’s, on the same question and the same day. If the saved answer describes the brand wrongly, murmur helps the company correct it and position the brand the right way in AI models.

Frequently asked questions

How many screenshots are enough to prove a result?

No number of screenshots proves brand presence, because each screenshot is an answer chosen by someone. The result is proven with the list of buyer questions, run in the same AI models over more than one round. That list runs from dozens to hundreds of questions, and ten are not enough.

Do two people who ask the same question see the same screenshot?

Not always: two people who ask the same question can receive different answers. In ChatGPT, according to OpenAI, the region of the person asking and, with memory turned on, what the person shared before can factor into the searches that build the answer. And the same person, asking again, can also receive a different list of brands.

Does automatic counting of answers make the screenshot unnecessary?

No: automatic counting speeds up the work, but a sample of the answers is checked against the image and the saved text. The program can attribute to the brand the answer about a company with a similar name, or count as a recommendation a brand that was only cited as a source. The part that automates well is in the answer about how to automate the monitoring of AI citations.

Can a screenshot be used to request the correction of a wrong answer?

Yes: the dated screenshot records the error, along with the exact question and the sources the answer cited. The correction itself is made at the source of the error, from the company’s site to the registries the AI reads.

How do I know whether a screenshot an agency showed is reliable?

Ask for the list the screenshot came from and the total number of questions, because without both nobody knows whether it is the rule or the exception. An agency that monitors brand presence shows the number first, with the base, and uses the screenshot as an example. The screenshot in place of the report is among the warning signs before hiring a GEO agency.

See the answers your buyer receives today

Before the first screenshot, see what AI models answer today when someone is looking for what your company sells. With no sign-up, murmur’s free diagnostic asks only for the site URL and returns the AI answers in less than two minutes. murmur’s sector studies show who AI models recommend in other markets. Each one includes the number of questions, the AI models and the month, and reflects a single round.

Read also

References