murmur

murmur · sector study · September 2026

What AI models answer when someone is looking for a consórcio administrator

25 questions asked in 3 AI tools, 75 answers saved with a screenshot. No question includes a company name: these are the questions someone types before choosing who to do the consórcio with.

This study does not pick a winner. The count is the same for everyone: the name is written in the answer or it is not. Anyone appearing zero times is not included on this page, and no company commissioned, reviewed or paid for this study.

01 · who appears

Two independent administrators open the list; Porto Seguro, the first one tied to a bank or insurer, comes third

This page lists the consórcio administrators that AI cites, both independent ones and those tied to a bank, credit union, insurer, vehicle manufacturer or retailer. There are 27 in total: 12 independent, 8 tied to a bank, 6 from manufacturers and one from retail. Embracon appears in 50 of the 75 answers (67%), Rodobens in 44 and Porto Seguro in 39. Of the top eight, five are tied to a bank; the third independent, Ademicon, comes 4th, with 32. Six are foreign groups with an administrator in Brazil and carry the tag; the most cited of them is Santander, in 16.

Counting by answer, some independent administrator appears in 63 of the 75, some bank-tied one in 52, some manufacturer one in 10 and the retail one in 7. In 66 of the 75 answers AI cites two administrators or more, and in 9, none.

administratorin how many of the 75 answersshare of all mentionsaverage place in the listin how many of the 25 questions
Embracon50 67%14.0%3.021
Rodobens44 59%12.4%3.221
Porto Seguro39 52%11.0%3.620
Ademicon32 43%9.0%3.220
Itaú24 32%6.7%4.416
Bradesco23 31%6.5%4.716
Sicredi21 28%5.9%3.413
Caixa18 24%5.1%3.213
Banco do Brasil16 21%4.5%4.412
Mycon16 21%4.5%2.712
Santander foreign16 21%4.5%4.913
Sicoob10 13%2.8%3.09
HS Consórcios9 12%2.5%5.38
Consórcio Magalu7 9%2.0%5.17
Klubi7 9%2.0%2.66
Honda foreign6 8%1.7%4.85
Servopa4 5%1.1%6.84
Randon2 3%0.6%6.52
Volkswagen foreign2 3%0.6%6.02
Yamaha foreign2 3%0.6%3.02
Âncora2 3%0.6%4.01
Canopus1 1%0.3%2.01
Gazin1 1%0.3%3.01
Multimarcas1 1%0.3%5.01
Remaza1 1%0.3%6.01
Scania foreign1 1%0.3%5.01
Volvo foreign1 1%0.3%4.01
How to read it. The second column is in how many answers the name appeared. The third is the slice the administrator takes of everything cited in the table: the 27 add up to 356 mentions and this column divides that pie. The fourth is where in the list the name usually appears: 1.0 would mean always the first name. Each bank counts through its own consórcio administrator; Sicredi and Sicoob are credit unions, and Porto Seguro is an insurer. Those with the tag foreign are a foreign group with a consórcio administrator in Brazil; without the tag, it is Brazilian.
02 · the question category

In the generic question the bank comes along; when the question asks for an independent one, it drops to half of the answers

The 25 questions were written in five categories. In the general recommendation, from those who just want the best administrator, bank and independent appear side by side: the 15 answers bring an independent one in 100% and a bank in 100%. In the category outside the bank, from those asking for an independent, digital or non-bank administrator, the independent one stays at 100% and the bank drops to 52%.

question category1st2nd3rd4th
general recommendation 15 answersPorto Seguro 87%Rodobens 80%Embracon 73%Bradesco 53%
outside the bank 21 answersEmbracon 71%Ademicon 62%Rodobens 52%Porto Seguro 43%
by profile 15 answersEmbracon 80%Rodobens 73%Ademicon 47%Sicredi 40%
by feature 15 answersEmbracon 73%Porto Seguro 73%Rodobens 67%Itaú 53%
informational 9 answersBradesco 11%Embracon 11%Itaú 11%Porto Seguro 11%

In the 9 informational answers, from those asking how much the administration fee costs, whether consórcio or financing is more worthwhile and how to choose a safe administrator, company names almost never come up: some administrator from the table appears in 2 of the 9. In the rest, AI explains the product and tells you to check the authorization with the Banco Central.

03 · one tool is not another

Each tool has its own administrators

Apart from the top two, which appear almost the same across the three tools, the rest of the list changes depending on where you ask. Sicoob appears in 6 ChatGPT answers and in 1 from Claude; Bradesco appears in 12 Claude answers and in 2 from Google; Caixa appears in 10 Claude answers and in 3 from Google; Mycon appears in 10 Google answers and in 3 from ChatGPT; Klubi appears in 6 Google answers and in none from Claude. For these administrators, the same question asked in another tool often does not bring the name.

administratorChatGPT
25 answers
Claude
25 answers
Google
25 answers
Embracon161717
Rodobens141416
Porto Seguro121611
Ademicon15611
Itaú6126
Bradesco9122
Sicredi777
Caixa5103
Banco do Brasil754
Mycon3310
Santander foreign3103
Sicoob613
04 · what stayed out of the table

Who AI cites and does not enter the comparison

Manufacturer brand whose consórcio is administered by another company: Fiat (1), John Deere (1). A company from São José do Rio Preto, the city of the machine that asked the questions, which ChatGPT cited because of the city: Tarraf (1). All were counted the same way.

Three names also appear that sell no consórcio at all and serve as a reference for AI: Banco Central (48), Reclame Aqui (14), ABAC (9).

05 · where the answer comes from

The site most read by AI models belongs to no company

In 40 of the 75 answers you can see which sites the tool consulted (24 in ChatGPT and 16 in Claude). There were 50 different sites, and the most used of all is the Banco Central ranking of administrators, in 21 of the 40 answers counting its 3 addresses. ABAC appears in 7. The most read administrator site is Ademicon's, in 5.

What the tool reads also appears in what it writes: when an administrator's site was consulted, its name appeared in the answer 100% of the time. When it was not consulted, the name appeared in 16%.

siteused as a source in how many of the 40
bcb.gov.br13
consorciometro.com.br6
www3.bcb.gov.br6
abac.org.br5
ademicon.com.br5
caixaconsorcio.com.br4
embracon.com.br4
idinheiro.com.br4
itau.com.br3
renovainvest.com.br3
rodobens.com.br3
sicredi.com.br3
administratorsite used as a sourcename written in the answer
Embracon4 of 4033 of 50
Rodobens3 of 4028 of 50
Porto Seguro4 of 4028 of 50
Ademicon5 of 4021 of 50
Itaú3 of 4018 of 50
Bradesco1 of 4021 of 50
Sicredi3 of 4014 of 50
Caixa4 of 4015 of 50
What this section does not cover. Google does not show the list of sites consulted in the answers we captured, so it stays out of this count, and only this one.
06 · how we measure

How we measure

  • We asked the 25 questions in 3 tools, once each, in September 2026: ChatGPT, Claude and Google. That is 75 answers. Each question was asked in a clean window, temporary conversation without history, from an IP in Brazil. We saved every screenshot.
  • Seven of the 25 questions ask for an independent or digital administrator, and that is intentional: they form the "outside the bank" category in section 02. The other eighteen suggest nothing, and the first five are open on purpose, to measure the contrast. The 25 questions are published in section 08.
  • ChatGPT answered by city in two questions. In two of the 25 answers it added a customer service block in the city the question came from and cited a local administrator. We kept the answers as they came and the local company is disclosed in section 04.
  • No question includes a company name, and none mentions a city.
  • We count only when AI writes the name in the answer. Site cards and company profiles that appear around the answer are left out.
  • The names in the table came from the answers themselves, and each one was checked on the company's site. We did not start from a ready-made list.
07 · limits

What this study does not say

  • Nothing about which administrator is better, cheaper or safer. What is measured is what AI models answer, not the quality of the group nor the fee charged.
  • Nothing about how much each thing is searched. The 25 questions reflect how people ask, not a sample weighted by search volume.
  • Nothing about what AI answers for you. Answers vary with the preceding conversation, region and day. This is a September 2026 snapshot in a clean window.
08 · the questions

The 25 questions, in full

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

  1. 01qual a melhor administradora de consorcio
  2. 02qual o melhor consorcio de imovel
  3. 03qual o melhor consorcio de carro
  4. 04me indique uma administradora de consorcio confiavel
  5. 05qual consorcio tem a menor taxa de administracao
  6. 06qual a melhor administradora de consorcio independente que nao seja banco
  7. 07qual consorcio da para contratar 100% online sem ir a agencia
  8. 08qual administradora de consorcio nao e ligada a banco nem a montadora
  9. 09existe consorcio digital de fintech ou startup que valha a pena
  10. 10qual consorcio tem o melhor aplicativo para acompanhar a cota
  11. 11qual administradora de consorcio especializada e melhor que a do banco
  12. 12qual consorcio de imovel tem menos reclamacao no banco central
  13. 13qual administradora de consorcio aceita MEI e autonomo sem holerite
  14. 14qual consorcio indicar para quem teve o financiamento negado
  15. 15qual o melhor consorcio para comprar imovel na planta ou terreno
  16. 16qual o melhor consorcio para caminhao maquina agricola ou frota
  17. 17qual o melhor consorcio de servico para reforma viagem ou cirurgia
  18. 18qual administradora de consorcio permite lance embutido
  19. 19qual consorcio tem parcela reduzida ate a contemplacao
  20. 20onde comprar cota de consorcio ja contemplada com seguranca
  21. 21qual administradora de consorcio contempla mais rapido
  22. 22qual consorcio deixa usar o FGTS no lance do imovel
  23. 23quanto custa a taxa de administracao de um consorcio
  24. 24vale mais a pena consorcio ou financiamento para comprar imovel
  25. 25como escolher uma administradora de consorcio segura