murmur

murmur · sector study · September 2026

What AI models answer when a company looks for decarbonization consulting

25 questions asked across 3 AI tools, 75 answers saved with a screenshot. No question includes a company name: these are the questions a sustainability or operations manager types before hiring emissions inventory or a decarbonization plan.

This study does not pick a winner. The count is the same for everyone: the name is written in the answer or it is not. Anyone appearing zero times is not included on this page, and no company commissioned, reviewed or paid for this study.

01 · who appears

WayCarbon appears in one third of the answers; the next four are the big audit firms, all foreign

This page lists the decarbonization companies, Brazilian and foreign: emissions inventory and net zero target consulting, carbon management platforms and carbon credit projects. There are 103 in total. WayCarbon appears in 25 of the 75 answers (33%), EY in 24 and PwC in 22.

Deloitte appears in 21 and KPMG in 18: the four big audit firms, all foreign, take second through fifth place. After them come the Brazilian firms Ambipar, with 16, and Eccaplan, with 14. The 51 foreign companies account for 58% of the mentions in the table. Bureau Veritas, which verifies the inventory rather than producing it, appears in 18 answers and stays out of the table (section 04).

In 56 of the 75 answers the AI cites two companies or more; in 1, it cites only one; and in 18, none.

companyin how many of the 75 answersshare of all mentionsaverage place in the listin how many of the 25 questions
WayCarbon25 33%6.8%2.017
EY foreign24 32%6.5%4.915
PwC foreign22 29%5.9%6.214
Deloitte foreign21 28%5.7%5.514
KPMG foreign18 24%4.9%6.914
Ambipar16 21%4.3%4.112
Eccaplan14 19%3.8%2.89
Mangue Tech9 12%2.4%2.78
Carbonext8 11%2.2%6.06
Greenly foreign8 11%2.2%4.54
McKinsey foreign7 9%1.9%5.35
SAP foreign7 9%1.9%6.74
Sweep foreign7 9%1.9%3.34
Watershed foreign7 9%1.9%3.14
BCG foreign6 8%1.6%5.85
Carbon Free Brasil6 8%1.6%3.24
ERM foreign6 8%1.6%6.56
Persefoni foreign6 8%1.6%2.54
Sustainable Carbon6 8%1.6%3.55
South Pole foreign5 7%1.4%4.44
Accenture foreign4 5%1.1%8.04
Biofílica4 5%1.1%4.22
EcoVadis foreign4 5%1.1%5.82
Green Domus foreign4 5%1.1%2.54
MOSS4 5%1.1%9.04
Microsoft Sustainability Manager foreign4 5%1.1%7.03
Salesforce Net Zero Cloud foreign4 5%1.1%8.04
Arcadis foreign3 4%0.8%4.73
Bain foreign3 4%0.8%7.33
Carbon Trust foreign3 4%0.8%7.73
Conscience Carbon3 4%0.8%6.03
Deep ESG3 4%0.8%3.73
GSS Sustentabilidade3 4%0.8%6.33
Green Solutions3 4%0.8%4.73
Mombak3 4%0.8%3.72
Normative foreign3 4%0.8%4.02
Schneider Electric foreign3 4%0.8%8.32
ACV Brasil2 3%0.5%1.01
ACX foreign2 3%0.5%3.01
Anthesis foreign2 3%0.5%4.52
BDS Consultoria Ambiental2 3%0.5%3.52
Carbonova2 3%0.5%2.02
Comerc Energia2 3%0.5%2.01
Dcycle foreign2 3%0.5%4.52
Emisfera Agro2 3%0.5%3.02
GP Carbon2 3%0.5%1.51
IBM Envizi foreign2 3%0.5%4.02
Instituto Via Green2 3%0.5%1.02
Master Ambiental2 3%0.5%3.02
NaturAll Carbon2 3%0.5%1.51
Onearth2 3%0.5%3.02
Ororo2 3%0.5%4.52
Plan A foreign2 3%0.5%6.02
Sphera foreign2 3%0.5%3.02
YESG2 3%0.5%5.52
How to read it. The second column is how many answers the name appeared in. The third is the share each one takes of everything cited in the table: the 103 add up to 370 mentions and this column splits that pie. The fourth is where in the list the name usually appears: 1.0 would be always first. The table includes those appearing twice or more; the others come right below. Those with the tag foreign are multinational consultancies or foreign software; without the tag, the company is Brazilian.

Cited once: ARCA Sustentabilidade, Argustech, Bartu, BlockC, BRCarbon, Bridge3, Descarboniza+, E2Carbon, Eco Restaura, Ecofinance, EN2 Consultoria Ambiental, Geocarbon, GETS Ambiental, IEAGA, Iniciativa Verde, Inovae Consultoria, KeyAssociados, Krona Ambiental, MOWA Carbon, MyCarbon, Neutraliza Carbono, Personal CO2 Zero, Planton, Sense Agtech, Smith Döll, Systemica; foreign ABGI, Achilles, Baker Tilly, BeZero, Calyx, Carbon Complete, CarbonCloud, EBP, HowGood, ICF, Indigo Ag, Metrikflow, OpenClimat, Oracle, Quantis, ReFlow, RSM, SimaPro, Sustable, Sylvera, Systemiq, Xpansiv.

02 · the question category

WayCarbon leads in the open question and in the one that states the type of company; when the question states the service, EY moves ahead

The 25 questions were written in four categories. In the general recommendation, some Brazilian company appears in 87% of the 15 answers and some foreign company in 67%.

In the by type of company category, where the question states the type of company: industry, midsize company, agribusiness, supply chain, logistics, exporter and retail, some Brazilian company appears in 95% and some foreign company in 62% of the 21 answers.

In the question by service, EY appears in 12 of the 24 answers, PwC in 10, and WayCarbon ties with Deloitte and KPMG at 9. Across the whole study, some Brazilian company appears in 54 of the 75 answers, some foreign company in 41 and some verification body in 25.

question category1st2nd3rd4th
general recommendation 15 answersWayCarbon 47%Ambipar 40%Deloitte 33%
foreign
EY 33%
foreign
by type of company 21 answersWayCarbon 43%Deloitte 33%
foreign
EY 33%
foreign
PwC 33%
foreign
by service 24 answersEY 50%
foreign
PwC 42%
foreign
Deloitte 38%
foreign
KPMG 38%
foreign
informational 15 answers

In the 15 informational answers, from people asking how much it costs and how to choose, no company in the table is cited.

03 · one tool is not another

On ChatGPT the first is Mangue Tech, on Claude it is WayCarbon and on Google it is Ambipar

Mangue Tech appears in 7 ChatGPT answers and in 1 from Claude. WayCarbon appears in 17 from Claude and in 3 from ChatGPT. Ambipar appears in 11 from Google and in none from ChatGPT. The four big audit firms come from Claude: EY, PwC, Deloitte and KPMG each appear in 14 of its answers, and on ChatGPT in 3 or fewer. The same question, asked in different tools, returns different names.

companyChatGPT
25 answers
Claude
25 answers
Google
25 answers
WayCarbon3175
EY foreign3147
PwC foreign3145
Deloitte foreign3144
KPMG foreign0144
Ambipar0511
Eccaplan455
Mangue Tech711
Carbonext242
Greenly foreign341
McKinsey foreign250
SAP foreign241
Sweep foreign241
Watershed foreign241
BCG foreign042
04 · what stayed out of the table

Who the AI cites and does not enter the comparison

Body that verifies and certifies the inventory: Bureau Veritas (18), DNV (15), SGS (13), TÜV Rheinland (4), Instituto Totum (3), Intertek (2), AmSpec (1), Applus+ (1), Gaia Certificadora (1), Kiwa (1), NSF (1). All were counted the same way.

05 · where the answer comes from

The most read site is Mangue Tech's

In 35 of the 75 answers you can see which sites the tool consulted (22 on ChatGPT and 13 on Claude). There were 106 different sites, and the most used is mangue.tech, in 8 of those answers. The site of some company in the table was consulted in 22 of the 35.

When a company's site was consulted, its name appeared in the answer 97% of the time. When it was not consulted, it appeared in 4%.

siteused as a source in how many of the 35
mangue.tech8
eaesp.fgv.br5
gov.br5
conteudo.brasil.bureauveritas.com.br4
waycarbon.com4
dnv.com.br3
ororo.com.br3
portal.fgv.br3
pwc.com.br3
bndes.gov.br2
bureauveritas.com.br2
carbonova.ai2
What this section does not cover. Google does not show the list of sites consulted in the answers we captured, so it stays out of this count, and only this one.
06 · how we measure

How we measure

  • We asked the 25 questions in 3 tools, once each, in September 2026: ChatGPT, Claude and Google. That is 75 answers. Each question was asked in a clean window, temporary conversation without history, from an IP in Brazil. We saved every screenshot.
  • Seven of the 25 questions state the type of company that needs the service: industry, midsize company, agribusiness, supply chain (scope 3), logistics and transport, exporter facing CBAM and retail. They form the category in section 02. The first five are open on purpose, to measure the contrast. The 25 questions are published in section 08.
  • No question includes a company name, and none mentions a city.
  • We count only when AI writes the name in the answer. Site cards and company profiles that appear around the answer stay out.
  • The names in the table came from the answers themselves, not from a ready-made list. Each name was checked on the company's site, including those cited only once. Standards, programs, institutes, public bodies and clients cited as examples do not sell the service and stayed out of the count.
07 · limits

What this study does not say

  • Nothing about which company does the best inventory or the best plan. What is measured is what AI models answer, not product quality or price.
  • Nothing about how much each thing is searched. The 25 questions reflect how people ask, not a sample weighted by search volume.
  • Nothing about what AI answers for you. Answers vary with the preceding conversation, region and day. This is a September 2026 snapshot in a clean window.
08 · the questions

The 25 questions, in full

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

  1. 01qual a melhor consultoria de descarbonizacao para empresas
  2. 02qual empresa faz o inventario de emissoes de gases de efeito estufa da minha empresa
  3. 03me indique uma consultoria para montar a estrategia net zero da empresa
  4. 04quais sao as melhores empresas de gestao de carbono no brasil
  5. 05qual plataforma calcula a pegada de carbono de uma empresa
  6. 06qual consultoria de descarbonizacao para industria
  7. 07qual empresa faz inventario de carbono para uma empresa media
  8. 08qual consultoria de carbono para o agronegocio
  9. 09qual empresa ajuda a calcular as emissoes de escopo 3 da cadeia de fornecedores
  10. 10qual consultoria de descarbonizacao para empresa de logistica e transporte
  11. 11qual consultoria ajuda uma empresa exportadora a se preparar para o CBAM
  12. 12qual empresa ajuda o varejo a reduzir as emissoes de carbono
  13. 13qual software de gestao de emissoes de carbono para empresas
  14. 14onde comprar credito de carbono para compensar as emissoes da empresa
  15. 15qual consultoria ajuda a definir metas de reducao de emissoes baseadas na ciencia
  16. 16qual empresa faz o relatorio de sustentabilidade e clima no padrao IFRS S2
  17. 17qual empresa prepara a empresa para o mercado regulado de carbono no brasil
  18. 18qual consultoria faz inventario de emissoes no padrao GHG Protocol
  19. 19qual empresa faz a verificacao independente do inventario de emissoes
  20. 20qual consultoria calcula a pegada de carbono de um produto
  21. 21quanto custa fazer um inventario de emissoes de carbono
  22. 22como fazer o inventario de gases de efeito estufa de uma empresa
  23. 23o que sao as emissoes de escopo 1 2 e 3
  24. 24como montar um plano de descarbonizacao para a empresa
  25. 25minha empresa e obrigada a reportar as emissoes de carbono