murmur

murmur · sector study · September 2026

What AI models answer when someone looks for a supplement

25 questions asked in 3 AI tools, 75 answers saved with a screenshot. No question includes a company name: these are the questions someone asks before buying whey, creatine or a vitamin.

This study does not pick a winner. The count is the same for everyone: the name is written in the answer or it is not. Anyone appearing zero times is not included on this page, and no company commissioned, reviewed or paid for this study.

01 · who appears

Four Brazilian brands dominate the answer; the first foreign one, Optimum Nutrition, comes in fifth

This page lists the supplement brands, Brazilian and foreign: whey, creatine, pre-workout, collagen, vitamins and protein bars. There are 37 in total. Growth Supplements appears in 31 of the 75 answers (41%), Max Titanium in 26 and Integralmedica in 23.

The first foreign one, Optimum Nutrition, appears in 14 answers; the other ten foreign brands appear in three or fewer each, and the eleven together add up to 13% of the mentions in the table. In the 15 answers to the open question, Max Titanium appears in all of them and Growth in 14.

In 40 of the 75 answers the AI cites two brands or more; in 2, it cites only one; and in 33, none.

brandin how many of the 75 answersshare of all mentionsaverage place in the listin how many of the 25 questions
Growth Supplements31 41%14.8%1.614
Max Titanium26 35%12.4%2.712
Integralmedica23 31%11.0%3.312
Dux Nutrition22 29%10.5%3.514
Optimum Nutrition foreign14 19%6.7%4.87
Probiótica13 17%6.2%5.110
Essential Nutrition11 15%5.3%3.56
Vitafor10 13%4.8%4.46
Black Skull8 11%3.8%5.55
Nutrify6 8%2.9%3.85
Dark Lab5 7%2.4%4.23
Soldiers Nutrition5 7%2.4%5.04
Atlhetica Nutrition3 4%1.4%3.33
Nutrata3 4%1.4%4.02
Solgar foreign3 4%1.4%5.03
Dymatize foreign2 3%1.0%3.01
NewNutrition2 3%1.0%3.02
Now Foods foreign2 3%1.0%2.52
Sanavita2 3%1.0%2.51
3VS Nutrition1 1%0.5%11.01
Barebells foreign1 1%0.5%1.01
Bold1 1%0.5%5.01
Catarinense Pharma1 1%0.5%4.01
Centrum foreign1 1%0.5%1.01
Darkness1 1%0.5%13.01
Desinchá1 1%0.5%5.01
Equaliv1 1%0.5%2.01
Iridium Labs1 1%0.5%3.01
Lavitan1 1%0.5%2.01
Nature Made foreign1 1%0.5%2.01
Nordic Naturals foreign1 1%0.5%1.01
Nutren foreign1 1%0.5%3.01
Ocean Drop1 1%0.5%2.01
Pump Gummy1 1%0.5%3.01
True Source1 1%0.5%1.01
Universal Nutrition foreign1 1%0.5%5.01
YoPRO foreign1 1%0.5%3.01
How to read it. The second column is how many answers the name appeared in. The third is the share each one holds of everything cited in the table: the 37 add up to 209 mentions and this column divides that pie. The fourth is where in the list the name usually appears: 1.0 would be always first. Those with the tag foreign are foreign brands; without the tag, they are Brazilian.
02 · the question category

In the open question a brand always appears; when the question says who will take it, the brand disappears

The 25 questions were written in four categories. In the general recommendation, some Brazilian brand appears in 100% of the 15 answers and some foreign brand in 47%.

In the by buyer profile category, where the question says who will take it: someone just starting out, the woman who trains, someone who wants to gain mass, the runner, someone with lactose intolerance, the vegan and the older adult, some Brazilian brand appears in 33% and some foreign brand in 10% of the 21 answers.

In no category does a foreign brand make the top four; Optimum Nutrition appears in 7 of the 15 open answers. Across the whole study, some Brazilian brand appears in 41 of the 75 answers and some foreign brand in 20.

question category1st2nd3rd4th
general recommendation 15 answersMax Titanium 100%Growth Supplements 93%Integralmedica 80%Dux Nutrition 67%
by buyer profile 21 answersGrowth Supplements 24%Dux Nutrition 19%Integralmedica 14%Max Titanium 14%
by product 24 answersGrowth Supplements 46%Dux Nutrition 33%Integralmedica 33%Max Titanium 33%
informational 15 answersGrowth Supplements 7%

In the 15 informational answers, from people asking how much it costs and how to choose, a brand from the table appears.

03 · one tool is not another

Probiótica appears more in Claude; Nutrify and Essential, in Google

Foreign brands appear more in Claude: some of them are in 10 of its answers, 6 from Google and 4 from ChatGPT.

Probiótica appears in 8 Claude answers and in 2 from Google; Essential Nutrition appears in 6 Google answers and in 2 from ChatGPT; Nutrify appears in 4 Google answers and in 0 from ChatGPT. The same question, asked in different tools, returns different names.

brandChatGPT
25 answers
Claude
25 answers
Google
25 answers
Growth Supplements91111
Max Titanium8117
Integralmedica4811
Dux Nutrition787
Optimum Nutrition foreign473
Probiótica382
Essential Nutrition236
Vitafor244
Black Skull242
Nutrify024
Dark Lab131
Soldiers Nutrition221
Atlhetica Nutrition021
Nutrata201
Solgar foreign030
04 · what was left out of the table

What the AI cites and does not enter the comparison

Store or marketplace cited as a place to buy: Amazon (2), Drogasil (2), Mercado Livre (2), Droga Raia (1), Netshoes (1). Raw material from another company, cited as a product tag: Creapure (8), Verisol (2), Body Balance (1), Fortigel (1), Peptan (1). All were counted the same way.

05 · where the answer comes from

The most read site is a product comparison, not a brand's site

In 24 of the 75 answers you can see which sites the tool consulted (20 in ChatGPT and 4 in Claude). There were 37 different sites, and the most used is br.my-best.com, in 6 of those answers. The site of some brand in the table was consulted in 2 of the 24.

siteused as a source in how many of the 24
br.my-best.com6
gov.br4
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov4
ods.od.nih.gov3
comocomprar.com.br2
essentialnutrition.com.br2
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov2
promobit.com.br2
recomendex.com.br2
acsm.org1
adorocupom.com1
ajuda.vita.com.br1
What this section does not cover. Google does not show the list of sites consulted in the answers we captured, so it is left out of this count, and only of this one.
06 · how we measure

How we measure

  • We asked the 25 questions in 3 tools, once each, in September 2026: ChatGPT, Claude and Google. That is 75 answers. Each question was asked in a clean window, temporary conversation without history, from an IP in Brazil. We saved every screenshot.
  • Seven of the 25 questions say who is going to take the supplement: someone starting at the gym, the woman who trains, someone who wants to gain mass, the runner, someone who is lactose intolerant, the vegan and the older adult. They make up the category in section 02. The first five are open on purpose, to measure the contrast. The 25 questions are published in section 08.
  • No question contains a company name, and none mentions a city.
  • We count only when AI writes the name in the answer. Site cards and company profiles that appear around the answer are left out.
  • The names in the table came from the answers themselves, not from a ready-made list. Each name was checked on the brand's website, including those cited only once, and the shopping card that ChatGPT shows next to the text was not counted.
07 · limits

What this study does not say

  • Nothing about which supplement works best. What is measured is what AI models answer, not product quality or price.
  • Nothing about how much each thing is searched. The 25 questions reflect how people ask, not a sample weighted by search volume.
  • Nothing about what AI answers for you. Answers vary with the preceding conversation, region and day. This is a September 2026 snapshot in a clean window.
08 · the questions

The 25 questions, in full

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

  1. 01qual a melhor marca de whey protein
  2. 02qual a melhor marca de creatina
  3. 03quais sao as melhores marcas de suplemento do brasil
  4. 04qual pre-treino vale a pena comprar
  5. 05qual marca de suplemento tem o melhor custo-beneficio
  6. 06qual o melhor whey para quem esta comecando na academia
  7. 07qual suplemento e melhor para mulher que treina
  8. 08qual o melhor suplemento para ganhar massa muscular
  9. 09qual suplemento para corredor e atleta de endurance
  10. 10qual whey para quem tem intolerancia a lactose
  11. 11qual proteina vegana vale a pena comprar
  12. 12qual suplemento para idoso ganhar massa muscular
  13. 13qual a melhor creatina em goma
  14. 14qual a melhor marca de colageno
  15. 15qual o melhor multivitaminico
  16. 16qual o melhor omega 3 para comprar
  17. 17qual marca de creatina e pura e confiavel
  18. 18qual o melhor termogenico
  19. 19qual o melhor whey isolado
  20. 20qual a melhor barra de proteina
  21. 21como saber se uma marca de suplemento e confiavel
  22. 22como saber se o whey protein e de qualidade
  23. 23quanto tempo a creatina demora para fazer efeito
  24. 24creatina faz mal para os rins
  25. 25vale a pena tomar suplemento sem acompanhamento de nutricionista