murmur study · Black Friday 2026 · November 2026
Ask again and the AI changes its answer
We asked each of the 1,200 purchase questions five times to ChatGPT and Google AIO, from 13 to 15 November 2026, and compared the answers to the same question.
Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.
Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.
Each square is 5% of the answers about where to buy. The white ones put first the same store that the question had in first place most often across the five times.
The first store
The store in first place changes in 3 of every 10 answers.
We repeated each question five times. On ChatGPT, the store that appears in first place most often holds that spot in 71% of the answers; on Google AIO, in 67%. In the others, another store comes first.
ChatGPT
71%
of the answers repeat the no. 1 store of the question
Google AIO
67%
of the answers repeat the no. 1 store of the question
of ChatGPT's answers about which to buy repeat the no. 1 brand of the question.
of Google AIO's answers about which to buy repeat the no. 1 brand of the question.
The stores in the list
Two answers to the same question share only half of the stores.
Of all the stores cited in two answers to the same question, 56% appear in both on ChatGPT and 48% on Google AIO. The rest show up in one answer and vanish in the other.
The leading store in each category
Half the answers, another leader.
We split the five repetitions into two halves and looked at which store was cited most in each one. In 4 of the 10 categories, ChatGPT does not point to the same leader in both halves; on Google AIO, in 2. In one notebook, on ChatGPT, one of the halves ends with two stores tied.
| Category | ChatGPT, 1st half | ChatGPT, 2nd half | Google AIO, 1st half | Google AIO, 2nd half |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Air fryer | Amazon | Amazon | Magazine Luiza | Mercado Livre |
| Air conditioner | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza | Central Ar | Central Ar |
| Cell phone | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza |
| Headphones and speakers | Amazon | Mercado Livre | Amazon | Amazon |
| Refrigerator | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza |
| Notebook | KaBuM! | Amazon and KaBuM!tied | KaBuM! | KaBuM! |
| Perfume | Época Cosméticos | Beleza na Web | Época Cosméticos | Época Cosméticos |
| TV | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza | Magazine Luiza |
| Sneakers | Netshoes | Centauro | Netshoes | Netshoes |
| Video game | KaBuM! | KaBuM! | Amazon | KaBuM! |
What this means
One answer is not a ranking.
Whoever asks the question once and notes the store that appeared first is seeing one of the possible answers. To know who the AI recommends, you have to repeat the same question several times and count.
On Black Friday, in 11 of the 20 category leaderships (10 categories across the two AI models), the second store is so close to the first that you cannot say who wins. That is why murmur tracks the same questions every week and does not draw a conclusion from a single answer.