murmur

murmur study · Black Friday 2026 · November 2026

What AI models recommend on Black Friday

We asked 1,200 buying questions to ChatGPT and Google AIO, each one five times, from 13 to 15 November 2026, and read the 12,000 answers.

ChatGPT, without

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

ChatGPT, with

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

Google AIO, without

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

Google AIO, with

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

Each square is 5% of the answers. The white ones carry a warning about price or scams. "Without" and "with" say whether the question had "black friday" at the end.

The study

The same question, with and without "black friday".

Anyone about to buy a TV or a phone on Black Friday already asks AI where to buy and which one to choose. To see what changes when the date enters the question, we asked each question in two versions, identical except for the "na black friday" at the end, and repeated each one five times on ChatGPT and Google AIO.

12,000

answers read, from ChatGPT and Google AIO, from 13 to 15 November 2026.

495 pairs

of identical questions, one without and one with "na black friday" at the end.

10

categories: phone, TV, laptop, refrigerator, air fryer, air conditioner, video game, headphones and speaker, perfume and sneakers.

How to read it. Besides the pairs, there are 200 questions typical of the date, such as "vale a pena esperar a black friday para comprar uma TV" (is it worth waiting for Black Friday to buy a TV), and 10 that only exist with the date. Every number in this study says which questions it comes from.

The headlines

Headline 1Solid result

With "black friday" in the question, AI doubles the warnings about price and scams.

We asked the same questions in two versions, with and without "na black friday" at the end. In the version with the date, advice such as "confira o histórico de preço" (check the price history) and "cuidado com golpe" (watch out for scams) appears in 34% of ChatGPT answers, against 15% in the version without. On Google AIO, it goes from 17% to 36%.

Answers with a warning about price or scams

ChatGPT

Without "black friday"15%
With "black friday"34%

Google AIO

Without "black friday"17%
With "black friday"36%
5x

is how much the specific warning about fake discounts grows on ChatGPT: from 2% to 10% of answers.

8.5x

is how much it grows on Google AIO: from 1.6% to 14% of answers.

How to read it. The bars count the answers to the 990 paired questions, 2,475 without and 2,475 with "black friday" in each AI model. A warning about price or scams is any advice to be suspicious: price history, fake discount, inflated price, scam or fake site. The specific warning counts only "desconto falso" (fake discount), "preço maquiado" (inflated price) and "Black Fraude".

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

“Vale acompanhar os preços desde já para não cair em desconto falso.”

ChatGPT, respondendo a “qual a melhor air fryer custo beneficio na black friday”. A mesma pergunta sem “na black friday” não trouxe aviso em nenhuma das 5 respostas.

Headline 2Snapshot of the answers

Wait or buy? On that doubt, Google AIO warns in 96% of answers.

We also asked 200 questions typical of Black Friday, such as "vale a pena esperar a black friday para comprar uma TV" (is it worth waiting for Black Friday to buy a TV). In the questions about waiting or buying, ChatGPT brings the warning in 47% of answers. In those about price and real discount, the warning appears in 53% of ChatGPT answers and in 60% of Google AIO answers.

Answers with a warning about price or scams, by type of typical Black Friday question

Google AIOChatGPT

Buy now or wait

Google AIO96%
ChatGPT47%

General tips

Google AIO78%
ChatGPT57%

Price and real discount

Google AIO60%
ChatGPT53%

Where to buy

Google AIO53%
ChatGPT49%

Which product

Google AIO37%
ChatGPT29%
How to read it. Each bar counts one AI model's answers to one type of question typical of the date. In "Buy now or wait", there are 100 answers in each AI model, and 96% of Google AIO's carry some warning about price or scams.

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

“Muitas lojas sobem o preço semanas antes para "fingir" um super desconto na Black Friday ("metade do dobro").”

Google AIO, respondendo a “vale a pena esperar a black friday para comprar tv 55 polegadas”.

Headline 3Solid result for Amazon

On ChatGPT, "black friday" in the question puts the four retail giants in more answers.

In the questions about where to buy, each of the four gains 12 to 13 points. Casas Bahia more than doubles: from 11% to 24% of answers. They do not take anyone's place: the answer becomes 35% longer and cites 4.7 stores instead of 3.9.

ChatGPT answers that cite the store, in questions about where to buy

Without "black friday"With "black friday"
Amazon60%72%
Magazine Luiza57%69%
Mercado Livre46%58%
Casas Bahia11%24%
+35%

is how much the ChatGPT answer grows when the question mentions Black Friday.

4.7

stores cited per answer, against 3.9 in the version without the date.

How to read it. The hollow circle is the version without "black friday"; the filled one, the version with. Each line counts the 1,250 ChatGPT answers to questions about where to buy in each version. Amazon's rise passed the study's strictest test. That of the other three appears in almost every category, but sits at the limit of that test.

Headline 4Strong indication

On Google AIO it is different: Casas Bahia loses space and Americanas gains.

Casas Bahia falls from 33% to 21% of answers about where to buy. Americanas rises from 21% to 30% and reaches 54% in the questions typical of Black Friday, such as "qual loja é mais confiável na black friday" (which store is most reliable on Black Friday). Google AIO moves more stores around than ChatGPT.

Google AIO answers that cite the store, in questions about where to buy

Without "black friday"With "black friday"
Americanas21%30%
Mercado Livre48%56%
Magazine Luiza57%60%
Amazon42%49%
Casas Bahia21%33%

Americanas on Google AIO, in three types of question about where to buy

21%

of answers cite Americanas when the question does not mention Black Friday.

30%

when the question has "black friday" at the end.

54%

in the questions typical of Black Friday about where to buy.

How to read it. The hollow circle is the version without "black friday"; the filled one, the version with. Casas Bahia's drop appears in almost every category of the study, but sits at the limit of the strictest test. That is why the tag is strong indication, and not solid result.

Headline 5Snapshot of the answers

Amazon appears in 7 out of 10 ChatGPT answers about where to buy on Black Friday. On Google AIO, in 4.

Both AI models agree that Magazine Luiza and Mercado Livre are among the top. They disagree about Amazon: 72% of answers on ChatGPT, 42% on Google AIO. On Google AIO, Americanas joins the top group.

Stores most cited in questions about where to buy with "black friday"

ChatGPT

Amazon72%
Magazine Luiza69%
Mercado Livre58%
KaBuM!32%
Casas Bahia24%
Fast Shop23%

Google AIO

Magazine Luiza60%
Mercado Livre56%
Amazon42%
Americanas30%
KaBuM!29%
Casas Bahia21%
10 points

of distance between ChatGPT and Google AIO on Amazon when the question does not mention Black Friday.

30 points

of distance when it does: 3 times larger.

How to read it. Each bar is the share of the 1,250 answers from each AI model to questions about where to buy, in the version with "black friday", that cite the store at least once.

Headline 6Snapshot of the answers

TV and refrigerator: both AI models send you to Magazine Luiza.

In 10 categories, ChatGPT and Google AIO point to the same store in first place in 5. In 11 of the 20 leaderships, the first and second stores are so close that there is no telling who wins.

CategoryStore most cited on ChatGPTStore most cited on Google AIO
Cell phoneMagazine Luiza87%tie with AmazonMagazine Luiza89%
Headphones and speakersAmazon86%tie with Mercado LivreAmazon74%
RefrigeratorMagazine Luiza86%Magazine Luiza77%
LaptopKaBuM!84%tie with AmazonKaBuM!81%
TVMagazine Luiza92%Magazine Luiza79%
Air fryerAmazon83%tie with Magazine LuizaMagazine Luiza66%tie with Mercado Livre
Air conditionerMagazine Luiza64%Central Ar56%tie with Magazine Luiza
PerfumeBeleza na Web77%tie with Época CosméticosÉpoca Cosméticos75%tie with Beleza na Web
SneakersCentauro81%tie with NetshoesNetshoes76%tie with Centauro
Video gameKaBuM!90%Amazon84%tie with KaBuM!
How to read it. In bold, the categories in which both AI models point to the same store in first place. The number is the share of answers about where to buy that cite the store, with and without "black friday" combined. Tie means the second store is so close that there is no telling who wins.

Headline 7Snapshot of the answers

To find out whether the discount is real, the AI models send you to Zoom and Buscapé.

In questions about price and real discount, the two price comparison sites appear in about 3 of every 10 ChatGPT answers and in 4 of every 10 Google AIO answers. Reclame Aqui comes behind, as advice to check the store.

Answers that cite the site, in questions about price and real discount

Google AIOChatGPT

Zoom

Google AIO43%
ChatGPT33%

Buscapé

Google AIO42%
ChatGPT33%

Reclame Aqui

Google AIO13%
ChatGPT8%

Promobit

Google AIO9%
ChatGPT15%
How to read it. Each bar counts the 150 answers from each AI model to the typical Black Friday questions about price and real discount.

Original Portuguese research evidence, preserved as recorded.

“Eu não compraria antes de comparar o preço histórico no Buscapé e no Zoom.”

ChatGPT, respondendo a “em qual loja vale a pena comprar ar condicionado lg na black friday”.

Headline 8Snapshot of the answers

Ask the same question five times: the store in first place changes in 3 of every 10 answers.

We repeated each question five times. On ChatGPT, the store that appears most in first place holds that spot in 71% of answers; on Google AIO, in 67%. A single query does not tell you who the AI recommends.

ChatGPT

71%

of answers repeat the no. 1 store from the question

Google AIO

67%

of answers repeat the no. 1 store from the question

4 of 10

categories in which ChatGPT does not point to the same leading store in both halves of the answers.

2 of 10

categories in which this happens on Google AIO.

How to read it. Each square is 1% of the answers to questions about where to buy. The dark ones are the answers that put in first place the same store that the question most often had in first place across the five times.

How to read the tags

What each tag means.

01

Solid result

The difference passed the study's most rigorous statistical test, which considers the 10 categories and the 12 main comparisons.

02

Strong indication

The difference shows up in the analyses, but sits at the limit of that test.

03

Snapshot of the answers

Describes what the AI models said, without comparing the two versions of the question.

04

Mentioning is not recommending

We count the store or brand whenever it appears in the answer, including in product cards.

What the study does not say

A three-day snapshot of what the AI models say.

The study does not measure price, quality or reliability of any store: it measures what the AI models say when someone asks. It is a snapshot from 13 to 15 November 2026, with ChatGPT logged out and connections in Brazil. Answers change over time, with the account used and with the way you ask.