Updated on 7 November 2026, by João Leite, Founder of murmur.
When AI cites the competitor and not your company, find out which questions this happens on and publish the page that answers each one. ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Google AIO write the answer with what they learned in training and with the pages they find in search. AI cites the competitor because those pages talk about it: its site answers the buyer’s question, and lists, comparisons and reviews on other sites repeat its name. The answer changes when your company enters those pages, starting with your own site. The same questions, asked again over weeks, show whether it changed.
- Find out which questions AI cites the competitor on: ask your customer’s questions to ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Google AIO, and note who appears and which pages the answer uses as sources.
- Separate what AI does with each brand: naming, recommending and using the page as a source are different things, and each one has a fix.
- Check whether AI can read your site and publish the page that answers each question on it, with price, who it is for and case studies with names.
- Appear on the sites AI reads about your market: lists, comparisons, reviews and industry press.
- Ask the same questions again over weeks and compare how many answers your brand appears in and how many the competitor appears in.
Why AI cites the competitor and not your company
AI cites the competitor because the pages it uses to answer talk about the competitor, and not about your company. On a purchase question such as “qual o melhor sistema para academia” (“what is the best system for a gym”), ChatGPT searches the web, reads a few pages and writes the answer with the brands those pages name. A company that is not on those pages stays out of the answer, however good the product is. The guide on why AI recommends some brands and not others explains this choice in detail.
The competitor that AI cites usually has three advantages. It has pages on its site that answer the buyer’s questions, with price, who it is for and case studies. It appears in lists, comparisons, reviews and articles on other sites. And it has a name that AI links without doubt to its market, without confusing it with another company.
murmur, a GEO agency in Brazil that places brands in the answers of ChatGPT, Claude, Google AIO and other AI agents, found AI citing competitors in place of Visio, its client. Visio sells operations software for retail chains, franchises and food service. In June 2026, of the 2,560 AI answers about its market, 95% named a competitor and none recommended Visio. What held Visio back was the name: AI did not link “Visio” to a retail company, because of Microsoft’s diagramming program.
Find out which questions the competitor appears on and your company does not
To find out where AI cites the competitor, ask the AI models the questions your customer asks before buying and note who appears. Build the list with three types of question: the one from someone comparing options, the one from someone who wants to know the price and the one from someone looking for an alternative to the competitor. Use the customer’s words, such as “qual o melhor cartão de benefícios para empresa pequena” (“what is the best benefits card for a small company”), and not your site’s words.
Ask each question in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Google AIO, each one in a new conversation, without the memory of previous ones. Note in a spreadsheet the date, the brands named, the brand recommended and the pages that appear as sources. Repeat each question on different days, because AI answers change from one conversation to another. The result is the map of the problem: which questions the competitor appears on and your company does not, in which AI model and with which sources. The guide on how to measure brand presence in ChatGPT shows how to build and track this list.
The signs that your brand is invisible to AI
Your brand is invisible to AI when the competitor appears on purchase questions and your company appears on none. The signs show up in the study itself:
- AI names three or four competitors on the question “qual a melhor empresa de [o seu serviço]” (“what is the best [your service] company”), and your company stays out;
- asked by your company’s name, AI says it found no information, or describes another company with a similar name;
- the sources of the answer are lists and comparisons in your sector, and your company is in none of them;
- your site does not appear among the sources, not even on the question about the service that only your company offers.
One sign alone does not close the diagnosis. AI answers change from one conversation to another, and what counts is what repeats across several questions, across several AI models and on different days.
Your brand appears, but AI recommends the competitor
If your brand appears and AI recommends the competitor, AI knows your company, but did not find a reason to recommend it. AI does three different things with a brand: names it in the text, recommends it as an option for the person who asked or uses its page as a source, with the link next to the answer. Each one calls for a fix. A brand that is not named needs to be on the pages AI reads. A brand that is named and not recommended needs pages that say who it is for and why. And a brand that does not become a source needs a page that answers the question better than the others.
Your company’s page carries the company name in the paragraph that answers the question, and not only at the top and in the footer.
Your brand disappeared from AI answers and the competitor took its place: compare the sources
A brand that disappears from AI answers, with the competitor in its place, lost ground on the pages AI reads, or the AI itself changed. Before concluding that the brand disappeared, ask the same questions again on different days. One answer without your company proves nothing, because the list of brands changes from one conversation to another. When the absence repeats, compare today’s sources with the ones you noted before.
The most common causes show up in this comparison:
- the page AI used as a source went offline, changed URL or stopped answering the question;
- the competitor published a newer and more complete page about the same question;
- a list or comparison on another site, which named your company, was updated without it;
- your site started blocking AI crawlers, the programs that read sites for them, in a robots.txt change;
- AI got a new version, which searches and chooses sources differently.
Your site is not cited by AI and the competitor’s is: check whether it is read and the content
When the competitor’s site is cited and yours is not, check whether AI reads your site and whether it answers the question. Reading depends on robots.txt, the site file that tells Google’s and AI crawlers which pages they may read. OpenAI writes that sites that block OAI-SearchBot, its search crawler, do not appear in ChatGPT search answers. Ask the person who manages the site to check this file. Keep the answer in text on the page, and not only in an image, a video or a block that opens when clicked.
The page content decides the rest. Write the answer to the buyer’s question in the first sentence, with the subject named, and put in facts that AI can repeat: price, timeframe, who it is for and what is included. An institutional page of the “complete solutions for your business” kind does not answer any question, and AI passes it by. Compare the competitor’s page that appears as a source with yours: the difference between the two is the list of what still needs writing.
Publish the page that answers each question where AI cites the competitor
For each question where AI cites the competitor, publish on your site a page that answers that question, in the buyer’s words. A genuinely different question, a page, with the complete answer: the one that explains how much the service costs is not the same as the one that compares your company with the competitor. Different ways of typing the same question, on the other hand, stay together, on the page that already answers it. The page carries what AI uses to compare companies: how much it costs, how long it takes, who it is for, what is included and what is not. When the company does not publish the price, it publishes what the price depends on. Case studies with the client’s name give AI a result to repeat.
A brand’s own site matters more for a brand the AI does not know yet. In an Ahrefs experiment, a company that makes SEO tools, with 9,886 answers from ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Copilot, between February and May 2026, the new brand started appearing in 72 question-and-AI combinations where it had not appeared before. Of those entries, 82% came from answers that used a page from Ahrefs itself as a source. For the company the AI does not know yet, its own page is the doorway into the answer.
murmur followed this path with Mindo, a motion design studio in São Paulo that the AI did not know. On 29 May 2026, before murmur published any page, Mindo did not appear in any of the 63 answers in the diagnostic. The answers came from questions in its market, put to three AI models. The guide murmur wrote for Mindo was fully live on 22 June. On 13 and 14 July 2026, ChatGPT recommended Mindo in 23% of the 134 questions in its market, against 12% on the same questions on 25 and 26 June.
Appear on the sites the AI reads about your market
To appear on the sites the AI reads, start with the sources it already cites in your market: lists, comparisons, reviews and the press. Each source noted in the study is a concrete URL. It might be the list that names five competitors and not your company, the review site where the competitor has ratings and you do not, or the forum where customers compare the options. For each one there is a direct path. Ask the publisher of the list to include you, with the company’s data; ask your customers for reviews; answer in the forum, where the community rules allow it, with your name and role; and bring your own data to the sector press. The guide on Reddit and Quora to appear in AI models shows what each one is worth.
What other sites write matters more for a brand the AI already knows. In the same Ahrefs experiment, 94% of the new mentions of the known brand came from content on other sites. Fake reviews and paid praise without disclosure are outside this path: they mislead readers and expose the brand when someone finds out.
Compare your brand with competitors in AI models over time
To compare your brand with competitors in AI models, ask the same questions again on different dates and count how many answers each brand appears in. This calculation is called presence: the number of answers the brand appears in, divided by the total number of answers, which the market calls, in English, share of voice. Your brand’s presence next to the competitor’s, question by question, shows where the gap narrows and where it persists. Also note the sources in each round: when your page starts appearing among them, the answer is changing for the right reason.
The presence calculation is worth more than the position in a list, because the list changes with every answer. In a SparkToro study, 600 volunteers asked ChatGPT, Claude and the AI Overview, the AI-written summary at the top of Google search, 12 questions, totaling 2,961 answers. The chance of ChatGPT or Google’s AI repeating the same list of brands in two answers was below 1 in 100. The same study concludes that the percentage of answers with the brand, across dozens to hundreds of repeated questions, is a reasonable measure.
Few questions mislead. In a September 2026 text, Otterly, an AI monitoring provider, recounted what it saw when tracking a set of questions daily across seven AI models: swapping 10 questions for 100 reduced the fluctuation in recorded presence by approximately 73%. Where the question is asked from also counts: according to OpenAI, ChatGPT infers an approximate location from the user’s IP address and may pass it on to partner companies that run the search, with the goal of making results more accurate. That is why murmur does not measure the gap between your brand and the competitor from a team member’s computer: the questions go out from a dedicated server, hosted in Brazil, that always uses the same IP address and a browser set to Portuguese. That way, the city where the measurement is made stays out of the answer, and each week can be placed next to the previous one.
murmur shows in which questions the AI cites the competitor and writes the pages that are missing
murmur shows in which questions the AI cites the competitor in place of your company and writes the pages that answer each one. At murmur, a specialist dedicated to your brand studies the company and the sector and identifies who appears in your place in each question. This specialist takes care of the pages and closely tracks the result, from the diagnostic onward. The pages are published on a subdomain with the client’s brand, not on murmur’s domain: when the AI uses the page as a source, it is the client’s name that appears in the link.
At Visio, a murmur client, presence in AI answers went from 2% to 36% between June and July 2026, on the same 135 questions. murmur’s dashboard, included in the service, shows your brand next to each competitor in AI models, over time. murmur charges from R$ 5,000 per month, with a monthly contract, no lock-in and no cap on questions, hours or pages.
Frequently asked questions
Can you manipulate the AI so it stops recommending the competitor?
You cannot tell the AI to stop recommending the competitor, and trying to remove it from the answer with a trick is manipulation. In a 2024 laboratory test, text written to deceive the AI led AI models to discredit competitors. It was in two AI search engines and in plugins, not in ChatGPT search. Anyone who tries this puts their own site at risk. Google treats as spam any attempt to manipulate generative AI answers in Google Search, and also hidden text, placed on the page for the crawler and invisible to visitors. On Microsoft’s Bing, one of the partners OpenAI cites for ChatGPT search, the warning is repeated: the search engine’s webmaster guidelines say that anyone who tries to manipulate Bing’s and Copilot’s language models may see the site lose visibility or even drop out of search. The path that holds up is to publish, in plain sight, pages that answer the buyer’s questions and to appear on the sites the AI uses as a source. The tests and the rules of each platform are in the guide Manipulating what ChatGPT recommends: it worked in a test and puts your site at risk.
Can a competitor take over my brand in ChatGPT?
The competitor does not take your company’s name, but it can appear when someone asks about it in ChatGPT. This happens when there are pages that compare the two brands or that list alternatives to yours, and the AI repeats those pages in the answer. It is a different competition from the general market question, because what is at stake is the question with your company’s name. What protects the name is your site saying what the company does, for whom and for how much, and publishing the comparison with the alternatives, with the criteria stated.
What should I do when a competitor defames my brand in AI models?
Defamation is another problem: it is a false fact about your company, not the AI preferring another brand. Save the question, the answer, the date and the sources cited, because they show where the accusation came from. A false fact is corrected at the source, and the guide on how to correct wrong information the AI says about your company walks through the steps, from recording the answer to asking Google for legal reasons.
Can I do this alone or do I need an agency?
For the AI to stop preferring the competitor, the best path is a GEO agency following the case, such as murmur. In this competition, murmur uses data engineering to deliver an in-depth study of your company, the side-by-side comparison with each competitor, reliable measurement and, in the end, the result. Trying alone, without data and without measuring, can help in part, but it is unlikely to lead to the same result. At murmur, the same specialist studies your company, writes the pages and tracks your brand alongside the competitors.
Where to start, and where murmur comes in
Start with the questions your customer asks before buying: run each one in ChatGPT and in Google AIO. Note who appears and open the sources in the answer. murmur’s free diagnostic reads your site, writes the questions of your market and shows, without sign-up, what AI models answer when someone searches for what you sell. murmur’s sector studies show which brands AI models recommend today in markets such as gym management systems and restaurant management systems.
Read also
- Why AI recommends some companies and not others: the four reasons
- How to get your company to appear in ChatGPT: the step by step, with no registration or ads
- How to measure brand presence in ChatGPT: the step by step
- Why ChatGPT does not recommend your company, and what to show the boss
- How to correct wrong information ChatGPT says about your company: the step by step
References
- Ahrefs, “Self-Promotional Content Works, Until It Backfires (AI SEO Experiment)”, by Mateusz Makosiewicz, Ahrefs blog, 6 July 2026. https://ahrefs.com/blog/self-promotional-content-ai-seo-experiment/ (accessed on 25 September 2026).
- SparkToro, “NEW Research: AIs are highly inconsistent when recommending brands or products; marketers should take care when tracking AI visibility”, by Rand Fishkin, 28 January 2026. https://sparktoro.com/blog/new-research-ais-are-highly-inconsistent-when-recommending-brands-or-products-marketers-should-take-care-when-tracking-ai-visibility/ (accessed on 25 September 2026).
- OpenAI, “Overview of OpenAI Crawlers”, OpenAI documentation, undated page. https://developers.openai.com/api/docs/bots (accessed on 25 September 2026).
- Fredrik Nestaas, Edoardo Debenedetti and Florian Tramèr, “Adversarial Search Engine Optimization for Large Language Models”, arXiv, 26 June 2024, revised on 2 July 2024. https://arxiv.org/abs/2406.18382 (accessed on 1 October 2026).
- Google, “Políticas de spam para a Pesquisa Google na Web” (“Spam policies for Google web search”), Google Search Central, updated on 16 September 2026. https://developers.google.com/search/docs/essentials/spam-policies?hl=pt-br (accessed on 1 October 2026).
- Microsoft, “Bing Webmaster Guidelines”, Bing Webmaster Tools documentation, section “Prompt Injection and AI Manipulation”, undated page. https://www.bing.com/webmasters/help/webmaster-guidelines-30fba23a (accessed on 1 October 2026).
- Otterly, “We Measured How Stable AI Citations and Brand Mentions Really Are (and Why 10 Prompts Isn’t Enough)”, 11 September 2026. Questions tracked every day across seven AI models. Otterly sells AI monitoring. https://otterly.ai/blog/ai-search-visibility-stability/ (accessed on 30 September 2026).
- OpenAI, “Searching the web with ChatGPT”, OpenAI Help Center, no exact date on the page. https://help.openai.com/en/articles/9237897-searching-the-web-with-chatgpt (accessed on 2 October 2026).
- murmur, case studies for Visio and Mindo, published with the clients’ authorization: https://murmur.marketing/en/cases/visio/ and https://murmur.marketing/en/cases/mindo/ (accessed on 25 September 2026).
- murmur, free diagnostic and sector studies: https://murmur.marketing/en/diagnostic/ and https://murmur.marketing/estudos/ (accessed on 25 September 2026).